Cookie Magic

Custom sugar cookies, party decor, and holiday activity kits ✨ Making magic easy for every occasion

Cookie Magic brings a touch of sweetness and creativity to every celebration. Based in Maplewood, NJ, I craft custom sugar cookies that not only look amazing but taste even better. Whether you're planning a wedding, shower, birthday, or need a delightful gift box, I’d love to create something magical just for you. Let's make your next event unforgettable with cookies that are as special as your celebration!

12/20/2025

Early this summer a couple reached out to me to create cookie versions of their two beloved dogs as a way to include them in their wedding.

The process started as photos turned into digital mockups, a few rounds of revisions, and then finally a cookie prototype of each dog to make sure the details were just right!

And I finally had the pleasure of delivering their wedding order this past weekend, so I can now share them with you! 💍💕

12/18/2025

You know I'll never pick a favorite cookie order, but if I had to pick one, it would look a lot like this...

This mom was planning a "Wild One" themed first birthday, but since it was in late fall wanted to lean into a fall/winter color palette, and the result was stunning!

12/17/2025

No offense to the adults who come to my cookie decorating classes, but I’m always amazed by what these kids come up with!

They take… shall we say, complete artistic license 🤣

So I can’t wait to see what they’ll do with their cookies and pink, green, white, and black icing at next month’s Wicked-themed class ✨🩷💚

Is your kid waiting to unleash their creativity in the sweetest way possible? Join us at on January 10!

Register at the link in bio

12/13/2025

⛄❄ Now's the time to grab all of your holiday gifts for teachers, coaches, bus drivers, crossing guards and anyone else in your life that needs a little extra sweetness this holiday season!

And how cute are these winter character cookies? Each comes with a single full size cookie and character topper.

It's just one of many holiday cookie gifts I have available this year, check out them all in the link in my bio

⏰ But order soon, because orders close on Sunday!

12/10/2025

Dinos, but make them pastel 🦕🦖

With that direction and an inspiration pic of the party invitation for the color scheme, I was off to work creating these adorable dino-themed 3rd birthday cookies.

So which is your favorite?

12/04/2025

So grateful for the opportunity to play a small part in such a special celebration!

12/03/2025

🗓 Monthly custom order availability post: Holiday edition!

I'm fully booked out for the rest of December and currently booking into January and February.

Now's the time to reach out if you're celebrating something special in the new year and want to make sure it's extra sweet! 🍪🎉

12/02/2025

The perfect complement to popcorn 🍿 ? Cookies!

Popcorn shaped cookies... even better

This birthday girl celebrated at the movie theater, where her and her friends were certainly snacking in style!

What can I turn into edible cookie art for your next celebration?

12/01/2025

⛄❄ It’s time to reveal the winning holiday cookie designs!

You voted... I listened

✨ Holiday cookie pre-orders are NOW LIVE and are closing in 2 weeks (or when I sell out)!

🔗 Tap the link in my bio to see the winners and pre-order now

📍Maplewood pickup or SOMA delivery starting on December 16

11/29/2025

❄️⛄ Opinions please!

Which of these holiday cookie gifts should I offer this season? We have:

✨ Starbucks Bear Gift Card Box
✨ Holiday Character Single Cookies
✨ Holiday Treat for You
✨ Winter Decorating Kit
✨ Hanukkah Decorating Kit
✨ Christmas Decorating Kit
✨ Gourmet Stuffed Cookie Flight

I'm looking to narrow it down by a few, so let me know in the comments or in my stories which of these options you want to see next month!

11/28/2025

How will you accessorize your Labubu (sugar cookie that is)?

Join us next week at for a Family Holiday Labubu Cookie Decorating class. We'll go step by step, teaching you and your kids how to decorate 3 Labubu sugar cookies. The best part? Choosing your holiday accessories at the end!

Friday is sold out, but we still have some spots left on Sunday 12/7. Grab your tickets now!

Address

Maplewood, NJ
07040

Website

http://www.makemagiceasy.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cookie Magic posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Cookie Magic:

Want your business to be the top-listed Event Planning Service in Maplewood?