Small Town Buffalo

Small Town Buffalo Personalized cake toppers & party decor for birthdays, baby showers, holidays & all of your special moments.

This custom graduation cake topper was so much fun to create! Adding the baseball theme was such a fun little twist — th...
05/09/2026

This custom graduation cake topper was so much fun to create! Adding the baseball theme was such a fun little twist — this one may just be one of my favorites! ⚾️🎓💕





04/19/2026

POV: You found the perfect topper for your next party. ✨

I used a white glitter cardstock for the top layer here, but the best part is that you get to pick the other two colors. I don't use templates, so each one is made just for you. Which colors should I try next? 🍰💙

I’m currently taking new custom orders for the month! Click the link in my bio to grab yours and let’s get started on your colors. ✨

Personalized with your name and 2 favorite colors! 🩷

https://stbuffaloshop.etsy.com


04/19/2026

Level up your graduation party with a custom cake topper that’s as unique as your graduate! 🎓✨ We specialize in personalized names and school colors to make that Class of 2026 celebration unforgettable. Tap the link in bio to order yours and let’s celebrate the big day in style! 🥂🎂

POV: You found the perfect cake topper for the graduating class of 2026 🎓✨Level up your graduation party with a custom c...
04/19/2026

POV: You found the perfect cake topper for the graduating class of 2026 🎓✨

Level up your graduation party with a custom cake topper that’s as unique as your graduate! 🎓✨ We specialize in personalized names and school colors to make that Class of 2026 celebration unforgettable. Tap the link in bio to order yours and let’s celebrate the big day in style! 🥂🎂

https://stbuffaloshop.etsy.com


Make their graduation masterpiece extra special! ✨🎓There is nothing quite like seeing your senior's name in their hard-e...
04/13/2026

Make their graduation masterpiece extra special! ✨🎓

There is nothing quite like seeing your senior's name in their hard-earned school colors! Our Custom Layered Senior Cake Toppers are designed to bring that premium, 3D "wow" factor to your celebration.

Each piece is handcrafted with high-quality, multi-layered cardstock for a sturdy, boutique look that stands out in every photo.

✨ The Best Part? The acrylic sticks are removable! After the party is over, you can save the topper as a beautiful, flat keepsake to treasure for years to come!

Personalization includes:
💙 Your Senior's Name
💛 Custom School Colors
💙 Class Year (2026)

Rock on, little one! 🤘✨ I am so obsessed with how this custom "Threenager" cake topper turned out for Walker’s 3rd birth...
04/13/2026

Rock on, little one! 🤘✨

I am so obsessed with how this custom "Threenager" cake topper turned out for Walker’s 3rd birthday! Between the checkered pattern, the lightning bolt, and that skeleton hand, it’s giving all the cool-kid skater vibes. 🛹⚡️

I love creating these layered cardstock designs from scratch so they’re one-of-a-kind for your special celebration. Plus, once the party is over, you can just remove the acrylic sticks and keep the topper as a memorable keepsake! 🖤🍰✨

03/29/2026

🦖🎉 This adorable personalized dinosaur cake topper is perfect for your little one’s big day! Fully customized with your child’s name and age, and made to match your party theme 💚✨

Perfect for dinosaur birthday parties, toddler birthdays, boys birthday themes, and first birthdays! Comes in pink too!

🛒 Handmade with love
🎂 Perfect cake statement piece
🧁 Matching cupcake toppers & birthday banner available!

https://stbuffaloshop.etsy.com/listing/1856218257

03/27/2026

Can you guess which cake topper this is for? 🌸🩷

03/22/2026

Sending so much love and strength to my family and friends on Maui right now. Please lift them up with your prayers, thoughts, strength, and positive energy. 🙏🙏🙏

03/15/2026

Hop into spring with our Easter Bunny Cake Topper! 🌷

Multi-layered cardstock with a fun shaker center.
Custom name and age included! 🐰🌷

https://www.etsy.com/listing/4472415754

Address

Plant City, FL

Website

,

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Small Town Buffalo posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Small Town Buffalo:

Shortcuts

Share

Category