Simply Cutouts

06/02/2026

June Flavor Drop!

🎉 Vanilla Sprinkle:
-vanilla buttercream
- Supernatural rainbow sprinkles

🎉 Cookie Monster:
-vanilla buttercream
(dyed blue with Watkins natural food coloring)
-Benton’s chocolate chip cookie thin crumbles
-Benton’s chocolate cookie sandwich crumbles

🎉 Peanut Butter Chocolate Swirl:
-Peter Pan natural peanut butter
-chocolate buttercream
(flavored with Hershey’s cocoa powder)

🎉 S’mores:
-chocolate buttercream
(flavored with Hershey’s cocoa powder)
-Good and gather mini marshmallows
-Benton’s graham cracker crumbs

Try all 4 or mix and match. To order, message the Simply Cutouts Facebook or Instagram page. Pick up is in Hamburg. Sampler boxes are $20.00 each. Cash or Venmo is accepted at pick up. We are booked with custom cut-out orders for June, but sampler box orders are being accepted. Please give us a week’s notice to compete your order. Thanks! 😊

05/11/2026

May Flavor Drop! (a little late- sorry! we’ve been busy 😅)

🌸 Pink Vanilla Daisy:
-pink vanilla buttercream
(dyed with Watkins natural food coloring)
-semisweet chocolate chip center

🌸 Coconut Almond:
-almond buttercream
(flavored with natural almond extract)
-shredded coconut topping

🌸 Lemon Drop:
-lemon buttercream
(dyed with Watkins natural food coloring)
(flavored with natural lemon extract)
-sugar crystal topping

🌸 Black & White
- half vanilla buttercream
-half chocolate buttercream
(flavored with natural cocoa powder)

Sampler boxes are $20 each, please allow one week for us to complete your order. Cash or Venmo is accepted

**We are completely booked with custom cut-out orders for May and June, but will still be accepting sampler box orders. July is starting to fill up, and we’ll be closed from August 1st-17th to host/spend time with out of town family. Get your July orders in, and we’ll be accepting more custom cut-out orders after August 17th. Thank you everyone for your continued support and keeping us busy! 🫶🏼

04/01/2026

April Flavor Drop!

💐Vanilla Rose:
-pink vanilla buttercream
(dyed with Watkins natural food coloring)

💐 Chocolate Sprinkle:
-chocolate buttercream
(flavored with natural cocoa powder)
-Snackathon natural rainbow sprinkles

💐 Coconut Cottontail:
-vanilla buttercream
-shredded coconut

💐 Lemon Cream:
-yellow lemon buttercream
(dyed with Watkins natural food coloring)
(flavored with natural lemon extract)
-vanilla buttercream

Try all 4 or mix and match. To order, message the Simply Cutouts Facebook or Instagram page. Pick up is in Hamburg. Sampler boxes are *now* $20.00 each. Cash or Venmo -Smigelski is accepted at pick up. Thanks! 😊

02/28/2026

March Flavor Drop!

☘️ Chocolate + Vanilla Shamrock
-Green Vanilla Buttercream
(dyed with Watkins natural food coloring)
-Chocolate Buttercream Stem

☘️ Cookie Dough
-Cookie Butter Buttercream
-Mini Semi-Sweet Chocolate Morsels

☘️ Mint Chocolate
-Green Vanilla Buttercream
(dyed with Watkins natural food coloring)
-Mint Chocolate Cookie Crumble

☘️ Almond Joy
-Chocolate + Almond Buttercream
-Slivered Almonds + Shredded Coconut

Try all 4 or mix and match! To order, please message the Simply Cutouts Facebook or Instagram page with the following info:
-How many cookies/boxes you’d like
-Which flavors you want to try
-Best day/time for you to pick up

Pick up is in Hamburg. Since the cookies are smaller than our giant custom cut-outs, sampler boxes are *now* only $20.00 each. Cash or Venmo is accepted. Thank you!

01/31/2026

February Flavor Drop!

❤️Vanilla Sprinkle Heart
-Vanilla Buttercream
-Man vs. Cakes Natural Valentine Sprinkles

❤️Chocolate Peanut Butter
-Peanut Butter Buttercream
-Chocolate Buttercream Topping

❤️Cherry Almond
-Pink Cherry Almond Buttercream
(Dyed with Watkins Natural Red Food Coloring)
-Crushed Almonds

❤️Cinnamon Swirl
-Cinnamon Buttercream
-Vanilla Buttercream Topping

Try all 4 or mix and match! To order, please message the Simply Cutouts Facebook or Instagram page with the following info:
-How many cookies/boxes you like
-Which flavors you want to try
-Best day/time for you to pick up

Pick up is in Hamburg. Sampler boxes are $24.00 each. Cash or Venmo is accepted. Thank you!! 🥰

01/14/2026

January Flavor Drop!

❄️ Vanilla Snowflake:
-vanilla buttercream
-blue vanilla buttercream snowflake
(dyed with Watkins natural food coloring)

❄️Hot Cocoa:
-chocolate buttercream
(flavored with natural cocoa powder)
-vanilla buttercream dollop

❄️Coconut Snowball:
-vanilla buttercream
-shredded coconut

❄️Almond Ring:
-almond buttercream
(flavored with pure almond extract)
-crushed almonds

Try all 4 or mix and match! To order, please message the Simply Cutouts Facebook or Instagram page with the following info:
-How many cookies/boxes you like
-Which flavors you want to try
-Best day/time for you to pick up

Pick up is in Hamburg. Sampler boxes are $24.00 each. Custom cut-out cookies are $28.00 per dozen. Cash/check is accepted at pick up. As always, Barb will have change if needed

*NEW* Venmo is now being accepted before or during pick-up @ Jill-Smigelski for both sampler boxes and custom cut-out orders

Thank you for your continued support as we try something new! We look forward to hearing from you 👩🏻‍🍳

01/08/2026

Happy 2026! 🥳 We hope everyone had a happy holiday season and a great start to the new year. We enjoyed spending time with family over our holiday break, and have been experimenting with something new…

In addition to selling our custom cut-out cookies, we will soon be offering sampler boxes. Sampler boxes will include 12 individually wrapped circle cookies, with different flavored frosting/toppings. The cookies will be a little smaller than our custom cut-outs, and frosting will be made with all natural ingredients- no artificial dyes. This way you can feel a little less guilty indulging, and giving them to your kiddos (the whole reason for this idea)

There will be 4 different flavors to choose from each month. You can try all 4, or pick and choose which flavors you’d like to try. Each month there will be at least one cookie with our classic vanilla buttercream so if you like our cookies the way they are and want 12 of those- no problem!

I’ll be posting January’s flavors next week (once all of our supplies are in,) and the ordering can begin. You can send a message to our Simply Cutouts page or Instagram to order. The new prices for 2026 are listed below:

✨ Custom cut-outs: $28 per dozen (still the cheapest around!)
✨Sampler boxes: $24 each

As always, we appreciate your business, and look so forward to you trying our new flavors! 🤤k

06/04/2025

Can’t believe 2025 is almost halfway over! ☀️Although we usually ask for cookie orders to be placed at least 2 weeks in advance, this summer has filled up quickly and we are totally booked until mid August. Thank you for all of your orders so far this year, we look forward to taking more orders in August

05/30/2025

04/24/2025

As some of you already know, Jill from Simply Cutouts is HALF BAKED with baby boy #2, who is due in September. That being said, Barb will be working solo through the months of September and October, and Simply Cutouts will be taking a break to enjoy the holidays with family in November and December. Yes, that means no Thanksgiving or Christmas cookies this year! 😬 We apologize in advance for any inconveniences. We are still taking orders through October, and will pick up again on January 1st, 2026. Thank you for understanding! 💙