Stuft Catering

Stuft Catering Proud to offer a wide variety of unique flavors to Star Valley and beyond.

Happy 2026! Thru this weekend, book any event for 2026, and get FREE DESSERT included!
01/03/2026

Happy 2026! Thru this weekend, book any event for 2026, and get FREE DESSERT included!

Kahlúa pork is indulgence with a dark, velvety soul.Picture slow-cooked pork so tender it collapses at the touch of a fo...
12/29/2025

Kahlúa pork is indulgence with a dark, velvety soul.

Picture slow-cooked pork so tender it collapses at the touch of a fork, bathed in a glossy sauce infused with red burgundy, notes of salt, smoke and whispers of garlic, with a soft brown sugar-kissed sweetness. As it cooks, the alcohol melts away, leaving behind a rich, aromatic warmth that seeps into every fiber of the meat. The pork absorbs those flavors like a promise—savory, slightly sweet, faintly bitter in the most seductive way.

The edges caramelize into sticky perfection, while the inside stays impossibly juicy, infused with flavor. It’s bold without being loud, luxurious without being heavy. Each bite starts savory, blooms into a heaven-like richness, and finishes with a smooth, lingering warmth that makes you pause before the next forkful.

Kahlúa pork isn’t just a dish—it’s comfort food dressed in velvet. It tastes like late nights, slow conversations, and the kind of meal that makes people close their eyes when they chew.

I will be making eight of these tomorrow, for pickup kn the 31st (just in time for your New Years celebration!). They will be hot and ready to enjoy. Or you can refrigerate them for a later date. (Tho i highly recommend enjoying them as party of your festivities.).

$60 each roast. They will start out around 8-9 lbs. Pick up will be on Wednesday from noon-6 or so.
Preorders/payment will guarantee yours. I have limited space, so I’m only doing 10 of these this time.
Thanks for looking.

So for those of you that don’t know this, I’m besties with Santa. And he told me that he’s gonna be hanging out in downt...
12/20/2025

So for those of you that don’t know this, I’m besties with Santa. And he told me that he’s gonna be hanging out in downtown Afton by the arch tonight from 7 o’clock till 8 o’clock or so. That way people that haven’t had a chance to take their kids to visit Santa this year can go to say hi, tell Santa what they’d like for Christmas, and get some pictures. So, if you have a little kids, I’d make a point of getting down by the arch tonight. Just saying. And maybe share this with your friends.

12/20/2025

Thank you for the desserts/sweets orders for Christmas. I’ll be working on them this weekend for pickup on Monday and Tuesday.

Merry Christmas!

12/20/2025

Happy Holidays

🍫 Homemade Holiday Fudge – Available Tuesday evening/Wednesday 🍫I’m making fresh, homemade fudge today, available in tr...
12/16/2025

🍫 Homemade Holiday Fudge – Available Tuesday evening/Wednesday 🍫

I’m making fresh, homemade fudge today, available in trays that are a little over 2 lbs, $20 per tray.

Flavors Available:
💥Chunky with Nuts
💥Merry Maraschino Cherry
💥Cheery Chocolaty Fudge
💥Holiday Orange
💥Frosty Minty Chocolate
🔥Chewy Marshmallow
🔥Nutty Marshmallow
🔥Cherry Craisin
🔥Rum Cherry
🔥Salted Caramel Rum

A minimum of five (5) trays per flavor will be made. Prepayment guarantees availability. If demand requires, additional trays can be made beyond the initial five.

Pickup Options:
• Afton (near the Kodiak)
• In town by the Arch
(whichever location is most convenient for you)

Perfect for holiday gifting or treating yourself! 🎄✨j

Tomorrow (Monday) I’ll be making flavored (and original) hot fudge bottles. 1 pint is $12Flavors:Original fudgeMaraschi...
12/14/2025

Tomorrow (Monday) I’ll be making flavored (and original) hot fudge bottles. 1 pint is $12
Flavors:
Original fudge
Maraschino cherry
Mint
Sweet rum
Orange blossom

Preorders guarantee yours. Venmo or Cash App. Pics in post.
Pick up Tuesday near the Kodiak, or in town (Afton).

12/03/2025

🎄 Holiday Sweets Menu 🎄

Celebrate the season with our handcrafted Christmas desserts—made fresh, festive, and perfect for your holiday gatherings!

⸻

✨ Pies for the Season

Grinchy Key Lime Pie – 10” | $20
A merry twist on a classic! Bright green swirls and cheerful maraschino cherries in a buttery graham cracker crust.
Add a snowy meringue topping for $3.

Orange Dreamsicle Pie – 10” | $20
A creamy, dreamy blend of citrus and nostalgia—like winter sunshine in every slice.

Spiced Orange Cream Pie – 10” | $20
Warm holiday spices meet smooth orange cream for the perfect seasonal treat.

Lemon Meringue Pie – 9” | $20
Light, bright, and topped with fluffy golden meringue.

Lemon Blueberry Pie – 9” | $20
A festive pairing of tart lemon and sweet blueberries.

Coconut Cream Pie – 9” | $20
Filled with roasted coconut and velvety vanilla crème—a tropical Christmas indulgence.

⸻

✨ Holiday Cheesecakes

Plain Cheesecake – 10” | $20

Sea Salt Caramel Cheesecake – 10” | $21
Rich caramel with a hint of sea salt—simple holiday magic.

Cinnamon Roll Swirl Cheesecake – 10” | $21
All the cozy flavors of Christmas morning baked into a cheesecake.

Nutella Swirl Cheesecake – 10” | $22

Chocolate Mint Cheesecake – 10” | $21
A cool, chocolatey holiday classic.

Cherry Chocolate Cheesecake – 10” | $22

Chocolate Orange Cheesecake – 9” | $20
With a festive chocolate cookie crust.

⸻

✨ Christmas Treats

XXL Brownie Cookies – $6 each or 4 for $20
Thick, fudgy, and perfect for Santa’s cookie tray.

Artisan Caramels – $10 per pint
Small-batch, giftable, and delicious.
Available in:
• Sea Salt
• Spicy Cinnamon
• Sweet Rum
• Orange Blossom
• Butterscotch
• Peppermint

⸻

🎁 Holiday Pickup & Delivery

Pickup in Afton every Monday leading up to Christmas.
Delivery available with minimum purchase—just ask!

It’s Cyber Monday! And that means deals!!! 1. Gift certificates. Buy 2, get 1 FREE! Available in $25/$50/$100. No lim...
12/01/2025

It’s Cyber Monday! And that means deals!!!

1. Gift certificates. Buy 2, get 1 FREE! Available in $25/$50/$100. No limit. Great for gifts, or just to save yourself some $$. Good for 1 year from date of purchase

2. Key lime pies! Buy today, pickup on Wednesday. $18!

5. Catering for 50 people.
Pulled pork dinner
Includes super tender pulled pork
Homemade bbq sauce
Granolas baked beans
Rolls
Your choice green salad with homemade ranch OR thick and creamy coleslaw.
Includes all plates, napkins and utensils.
Drop off in Star Valley. Buy now, use it within 1 year from today.
$600
All offers are independent from one another.
Venmo, Cash App, Apple Pay and card all accepted.

Small business Saturday!
11/29/2025

Small business Saturday!

I just finished bottling Thanksgiving cranberry chutney. I made more than was ordered, so I have five extra quarts. $25...
11/24/2025

I just finished bottling Thanksgiving cranberry chutney. I made more than was ordered, so I have five extra quarts. $25 apiece. And I’m headed to Idaho Falls tomorrow morning, so I can take some with me and meet up on the way if that’s easier for you.  If you have not had this in the past, you’re seriously missing out. It is amazing with your turkey. Also peas, great with beef and pork pork. My wife loves to pour it on a block of cream cheese and scoop it up with crackers. There really isn’t a wrong way.

In this very difficult economy, I want to help out a little bit. So as of right now, I will be offering free birthday ca...
11/24/2025

In this very difficult economy, I want to help out a little bit. So as of right now, I will be offering free birthday cakes for any children under the age of 18. It’s not a huge cake. Just a simple, 8 inch frosted cake. But it will be delicious and pretty. Available in vanilla, chocolate or funfetti. There’s no commitment or obligation. I don’t care if you’ve never purchased from me in the past or if you ever will in the future. I just don’t think that kids should go without a birthday cake. Please just give me one week notice. You can message me here, or text me or call me at (307) 886-4486. And I promise that no one will know that it was given at no charge.

Address

Afton, WY
83110

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Stuft Catering posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Stuft Catering:

Shortcuts

Share

Category