06/08/2025
Is farm to bar cacao better than bean to bar? It very much depends if it’s fine or fashionable!
In my latest piece, I compare two Colombian bars: one “Single Origin, Farm to Bar Cacao” from Cox & Co, the other from bean-to-bar maker Nicola’s Chocolate. 🇨🇴🍫🇨🇴🍫
I’ve put them through the TTC test – Taste, Transparency, and Craftsmanship.
🍫TRANSPARENCY: What do we know about the beans and their journey?
Cox & Co
Is the whole process controlled by the company, as suggested in their strapline?
Not quite!
It is “supplied by Casa Luker estate,” who “work closely with local farmers”. Even when attributed to their supplier, farm to bar cacao makes little sense. Luker Chocolate sources from 15,000 farmers across Colombia and processes a blend of cacao into pre-made chocolate. The bars are then presumably made by Montrose Ventures Ltd for Cox & Co.
Not the level of transparency and control required for a genuine farm to bar claim.
Nicola’s
Cacao grown by 366 women of the Agromuvaras Association in Tumaco, imported by a fine cacao specialist (Belco), and made from bean-to-bar in Nicola’s small-batch factory, which is open to the public.
🍫🍫CRAFTSMANSHIP: How are the flavours crafted?
Cox & Co
If “handcrafted” for Cox & Co means made from pre-made chocolate in a factory producing over 20,000 bars a day, then in my book, it’s manufactured — not crafted.
Added vanilla extract helps achieve a standardised flavour profile.
Nicola’s
The crafting process is communicated clearly, illustrating the care and respect involved in flavour development — both at origin and in the bean-to-bar factory.
🍫🍫🍫TASTE: What are you tasting?
Cox & Co
Unpleasant aroma, but a familiar, uncomplex taste with a pleasant mouthfeel.
A classic, well-made industrial premium.
Nicola’s
Nuanced, layered, and an interesting flavour journey with a lovely aftertaste.
Food for the curious!
Read the full article and you decide which bars meets your criteria for taste, transparency and craftsmanship
LINK IN BIO TO FULL ARTICLE